Matt Schley
September 15, 2019 
Shōtarō Tokunō, the writer and illustrator of New Game!, is the very picture of a successful manga-ka. His manga has been running since 2013 and it’s been adapted into multiple anime series and even a video game.
But there was a time before all this success — and back then, says Tokunō, some manga editors treated him very differently.
That’s according to a series of tweets by Tokunō October 15, prompted by tweets from another manga-ka, Keiichi Tanaka. Tanaka teaches manga in university, and tweeted that many of his students have been dropped without so much as an email by manga editors they’ve been developing manga with. He reports that this has caused many of those students to lose their motivation and wonder whether they are cut out for a life in manga.
これによって学生たちが被るデメリットは「見切りをつけられたのかと自信をなくす」「あらたに描いたネームや原稿を他社に持っていっていいものか悩む」「返事が来るまで、そのネームや原稿を直していいものかどうか悩み、そこで手が止まってしまう」
— はぁとふる倍国土 (@keiichisennsei) October 14, 2019
Tokunō responded, saying that he, too faced “careless” treatment from editors before making it big.
“I have doubts about whether I want to work with someone whose disposition changes suddenly when my manga starts selling,” continued Tokunō.
“There were a number of editors whose attitudes suddenly changed as soon as New Game! started selling. It was really disgusting.”
Tokunō went on to praise his current editor, whose he said was the same before and after the success of New Game!.
Manga editors: they’re an essential part of the process, helping manga-ka hone their ideas. But it sounds like there are a few out there who are less interested in helping new faces than attaching themselves to rising stars.
とはいえ売れる前はぞんざいに扱って、売れたとたんに態度を変えるような人間と仕事したいかというと疑問がある。仕事のパートナーとして対等な付き合いができる編集者と巡り合えればラッキー…
— 得能正太郎 (@tokutaro) October 15, 2019
ヌーゲーム売れ出してから態度を急変させた編集者が何人かいて本当に気持ち悪かった。売れる前から今も昔も態度が変わらない今の担当はやはり信頼できる（ゴマすり
— 得能正太郎 (@tokutaro) October 15, 2019
Source: Otakomu
Related Posts
